The 2015 Chopin Competition – I Don’t Get It

Subjectivity

As you know if you’ve read this blog, before, I have absolutely no problem with subjectivity (see also how do I rate?) even if it may be controversial, and so I don’t hesitate putting my opinion out there, even if I may be a minority (e.g. with Staier’s Bach concertos that the whole world but me seems to love).

The 2015 Chopin Competition

However, things were slightly different with the 2015 Chopin competition. I mean we’re talking about one of the most important, if not the most important piano competition in the world, only held every 5 years! Former winners include legends like Martha Argerich and Maurizio Pollini, and in more recent years Yundi and Rafal Blechacz. Martha, Yundi, and Chopin specialist Nelson Goerner were part of the Jury this year!

So I felt rather belittled compared to those giants, and when the recording of the winner, South-Jorea’s Seong-Jin Cho came out on Deutsche Grammophon, and I didn’t really like the recording, I felt it must be me. Maybe these geniuses saw or heard something I don’t.

So I didn’t write about it yet on my blog and decided to give the album some more spins before I formally make up my mind. And then I must admit I forgot about it.

Seong-Jin Cho At the 2015 Warsaw Chopin Competition (Deutsche Grammophon 2015)

Song-Jin Cho Winner of the 17th International Fryderyk Chopin Piano Competition Warsaw 2015

Just recently, the two classical journals I subscribe to, Gramophone and Classica, came out with their latest issue, and both reviewed it. And guess what, in both cases, the reviewers were significantly underwhelmed (3 out of 5 stars for Classica, and rather negative comments from Gramophone).

So at least it wasn’t just me. Don’t get me wrong, this is fine Chopin playing, but compare his preludes to Blechacz, and sorry but we’re talking night and day in my personal opinion. And then you get Sonata No. 2. Compare this to Argerich herself, or Pogorelich, or Rubinstein, again, this is absolutely no match.

Not sure what happened, maybe Deutsche Grammophon just released the wrong takes, maybe Cho will develop over time, but so far I really don’t get it.

But even if you take the pressure of a competition and live performance into account, just compare Cho to Blechacz’ final performance in Warsaw 11 years ago, and really, there is so much more presence:

 

Obviously, you can’t have a new Argerich every year, but still my expectations were higher.

So what do YOU think?

My rating: 3 stars

In any case, you can find it here (Qobuz) and here (Prestoclassical)

 

6 thoughts on “The 2015 Chopin Competition – I Don’t Get It

  1. Pingback: Album of the Evening - Page 396

  2. Anonymous

    Classica that you mentinoned means the French magagine? If it is right it was 3 out of 4 stars. SInfini music 5 out of 5 stars and the Guardian 4 out of 5 stars and expressed it is ravishing.

    Liked by 1 person

    Reply
    1. Musicophile Post author

      Thanks for your feedback.

      First of all, let me clarify: I consider the “Choc” Classica’s fifth star, which is given only to “essential” albums. This pretty much the same system I use for my own star rating here. Their formal definition of 3 star is “Bon disque”, I.e. good album.

      I read Jessica Duchen’s 5 star review on Sinfinimusic. And I must agree with her comment about Cho’s excellent delicate touch.

      Looking back at my blog post, I actually missed to state what I particularly didn’t like about this album: it was the timing. In Patrick Rucker’s review in Gramophone, he mentions “rhythmic instabilities”, which I relate too, as I sense them too. And they don’t feel like planned rubato.

      In any case, I will follow Cho’s next releases with a lot of interest, it is clear we have a great talent here, I’m just not sure it is really appropriately captured in this album. Let’s see what he does in a studio next.

      Like

      Reply
  3. Pingback: Rafal Blechacz’ Magnificent Chopin Préludes | musicophilesblog – From Keith Jarrett to Johannes Brahms

  4. Pingback: Argerich vs. Angelich – Liszt’s B-Minor Sonata | musicophilesblog – From Keith Jarrett to Johannes Brahms

  5. Pingback: Another Disappointing New Release by Seong-Jin Cho | musicophilesblog – From Keith Jarrett to Johannes Brahms

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s