If you are a regular reader of this blog, you know I’m a huge Isabelle Faust fanboy.
Actually, I was mentally expecting another 5 star album when I saw what was just released, not suprisingly given my previous reviews (see here for the violin concertos of Mozart and Brahms, Brahms violin sonatas, her Beethoven sonata cycle is another reference for me, or her recording of Schumann’s violin concerto and piano trios).
Mendelssohn: Violin Concerto / Symphony No.5 / The Hebrides – Isabelle Faust – Pablo Heras-Casado – Freiburger Barockorchester (Harmonia Mundi 2017)
So, why don’t we get another 5 star review here?
I’ve mentioned before in my review of the Mendelssohn’s symphonies by Yannick Nézet-Séguin that I just cannot relate very much to symphony no. 5. So I’ll leave the judgment of that work to others. I was hoping to like Heras-Casado’s previous recent recording of Mendelssohn’s 3rd and 4th (review not published), but found it a bit too rough on the edges to be really of my liking.
So, what about the centerpiece here, the violin concerto? Well, I cannot be to hard on Faust overall, her playing is flawless and impressive as usual. So what’s not to like?
Well, here we go into personal taste. I’ve always really liked the “historically informed” practice (HIP) using little vibrato, and often gut strings. I really feel it adds something to the music compared to the classical performance style of the 1960s-1980s.
And that’s exactly what Faust does here. Very, very, very little vibrato. Her Stradivarius, “Sleeping Beauty”, always had a slightly slimmer, shinier tone than others, which usually worked wonders for me.
But I’m sorry, it really doesn’t work for me at all with Mendelssohn. I just miss the fat romantic sound.
I’ve now played this album four times in the last days to see if it grows on me. And I just can’t get over it. So I’ll always refer you back to other recordings, like Janine Jansen’s beautiful album with Riccardo Chailly (mentioned in my 25 Essential Classical albums). Vibrato all the time (even though Chailly has done a good job putting a little bit of HIP into the Gewandhaus’ playing). And I just love it.
But that is not to say you shouldn’t check this album out. This really is purely based on personal preference, both Heras-Casado and Faust do an excellent performance.
The highlight of this album to me is the Hebrides overture, where the above mentioned roughness of the Heras-Casado and the Freiburger’s really works to paint the rough Northern landscape.
My review: 3 stars (and really only based on personal taste, you need to check it out to form your own opinion)
You can find it here (Qobuz) and here (Prostudiomasters)
UPDATE Sep 23, 2017: The Guardian very much disagrees with me and gives this album a five star review. They like the roughness. Well, as mentioned above, you hav to listen to it to be the judge.
UPDATE Oct 5, 2017: Dave Hurvitz on Classicstoday has his full review behind his paywall, but I guess the title of the review gives his opinion away: “CD From Hell: Faust and Heras-Casado Starve Mendelssohn”. looks like this album generates rather strong reactions one way or another.
8 thoughts on “Isabelle Faust and Pablo Heras-Casado play Mendelssohn – Too HIP?”
I have been reading your blog for a long time because your musical taste on many issues similar to mine. This is how it is now about Isabelle Faust’s new recording. I downloaded it one hour before your new post arrived. (My best source is eClassical – Qobuz and Prostudiomasters are unreachable from my country as Sony Classical recordings are under territoral constraints.)
If I had read it before, I would not have bought it. Really this violin concert is beautifully played but not in its proper romantic style. The fast tempos of all movements do not allow this. The whole piece is a little empty for me.
In musical performances I met generally the opposite. It’s just as annoying to me as listening a Mozart aria in the style of verismo with very much vibratos.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks for your kind words. And it looks like indeed we share a common taste.
You really make it appear so easy with your presentation however I in finding this topic to be really one thing that I think I’d never understand. It kind of feels too complex and extremely extensive for me. I am having a look forward on your subsequent post, I’ll try to get the dangle of it!
LikeLiked by 1 person
Alex, happy to elaborate further, but could you let me on to which topic exactly you are referring to here?